As a carpenter, structurally it's fine. But I wouldn't have used it for a full stud appearance wise. You could have used it for a partition backer, or cut it for blocking.
Kind of my thoughts. As long as the shetrocker makes a mental note and don't try to screw there should be fine, even in that case,a little mud will fill the hole.
Structural Engineer here, I would leave it. Studs looked to be spaced at 16" o.c. which can handle a good amount of load, and the loading from the roof of a single family house isn't too much. For a 2x4, normal cross sectional area is 5.25 square inches. To be generous, if an inch is taken out of that stud, the cross sectional area is reduced to 3.75 square inches. A 2x4 at 70% capacity can still support upwards of 1500 pounds. So the numbers check out. But nothing wrong with playing it safe, especially if you have a ...thorough... inspector. :)
Change or sister another right next to it. That defect is right in the way of the sheetrock nailing pattern. No way to pass Sheetrock nail if the screw doesn’t penetrate the framing. Or just let it ride and see if you get caught
Add a better one beside it, nail them together and move on. Although a limited area of the project is shown, it looks like an above average framing job based on today’s standards. JS.
Pull it for the sake of the drywaller and homeowners. Why is this even a question? Imagine the drywall collapsing on install or the homeowner hanging a picture.
The sheet rocking isn't going to fail as the 4x8 or 4x10 sheet is going to be screwed in at so many more points than that single part of the stud. Pictures don't fall off of walls due to bad studs, they fall off due to bad anchoring methods. Most pictures are small enough that basic sheet rock anchors alone will support their weight.
Not only replace the stud you're focusing on but also the other two studs on either side of it. Make the newbie that used it replace it. Make the person who's supposed to be training the newbie replace the other two. Learn the right way to build a wall and the, "Why's" it needs to be done that way or get out of the trade. This kind of crap is a disgrace not only to the company that's paying their wages but also themselves. You can tell the character of a person by the quality of work they do. The yard probably would have taken back the bad studs if they wouldn't have been cut and nailed. Now it's too late. Waste of time and labor.
@@JPost55465 Hobbiest Finish Carpenter is a completely different animal to rough framing a house. With your work every bit will likely be in view. With Rough framing carpentry the finish surfaces will come way on down the line.
As a carpenter, structurally it's fine. But I wouldn't have used it for a full stud appearance wise. You could have used it for a partition backer, or cut it for blocking.
Kind of my thoughts. As long as the shetrocker makes a mental note and don't try to screw there should be fine, even in that case,a little mud will fill the hole.
Structural Engineer here, I would leave it. Studs looked to be spaced at 16" o.c. which can handle a good amount of load, and the loading from the roof of a single family house isn't too much. For a 2x4, normal cross sectional area is 5.25 square inches. To be generous, if an inch is taken out of that stud, the cross sectional area is reduced to 3.75 square inches. A 2x4 at 70% capacity can still support upwards of 1500 pounds. So the numbers check out. But nothing wrong with playing it safe, especially if you have a ...thorough... inspector. :)
😂😂😂😂 good one man, good one
Shout up load, you clown. It’s only to hold the board. You think it’s keeping the structure together….😂😂😂. Stick to the books lad…
That ain't right.lol😊
Sheet rocker will fail nail inspection….
@ragingrevenge1 do they inspect drywall screws on every house where you are?
Replace it with metal stud.
Just to make somebody 10 years down the road say “whattttt the heeeeccckkk?”
Replace immediately
Why was it installed? I'm sure it looked like that off the truck.
Change or sister another right next to it. That defect is right in the way of the sheetrock nailing pattern. No way to pass Sheetrock nail if the screw doesn’t penetrate the framing. Or just let it ride and see if you get caught
Leave it, as it has zero affect, other than drywall screw. Keep the board in.
How did it leave the saw mill? Who took it off the stack and installed it?
I would have returned when it got delivered. I check each pc. I'm paying for it it better be straight, no knots, no bows!!!
Yes Replace the Studs.
won’t make a huge difference always try to use good studs all the way around but it happens
I would of switched it out, if dry walling it would look like a wash board wall.
Add a better one beside it, nail them together and move on. Although a limited area of the project is shown, it looks like an above average framing job based on today’s standards. JS.
"Above average" because everyone has gotten used to shit work being done.
It's on a partition wall, not a load bearing wall. Leave it.
It is a LB wall.
I’d remove it. Why bother with it? Use it for blocking or something. It’d be an easy fix to replace it.
I would leave it unless the customer wanted me to change it.
Leave it. I will get covered with drywall 😂
Sister it up
Well my custom personal house NO, but for just any mass produce homes YEAH all of them have these in it just cheaply built.
Too bad you seen it... Now you know it's there... The power of vision😂
Certified Astronaut here... I have idea what you should do.
Add another to it.
Replace it
Replace it !
Wood glue and saw dust pack that shit tight and let the drywallers fix any other f ups
Yes
Never use grade 3 for structural or framing. You have one person running a screw through that and it'll fall apart
Pull it for the sake of the drywaller and homeowners. Why is this even a question? Imagine the drywall collapsing on install or the homeowner hanging a picture.
The sheet rocking isn't going to fail as the 4x8 or 4x10 sheet is going to be screwed in at so many more points than that single part of the stud.
Pictures don't fall off of walls due to bad studs, they fall off due to bad anchoring methods. Most pictures are small enough that basic sheet rock anchors alone will support their weight.
Sister it ?
Maybe
Id just double up
Not only replace the stud you're focusing on but also the other two studs on either side of it. Make the newbie that used it replace it. Make the person who's supposed to be training the newbie replace the other two. Learn the right way to build a wall and the, "Why's" it needs to be done that way or get out of the trade. This kind of crap is a disgrace not only to the company that's paying their wages but also themselves. You can tell the character of a person by the quality of work they do. The yard probably would have taken back the bad studs if they wouldn't have been cut and nailed. Now it's too late. Waste of time and labor.
Nope, not there!
I know.. the 8 dollar cost of a 2x4 and 60 seconds to remove it and replace is far too much to ask from a builder
Not sure where you are buying your lumber but number 2 DF is .30 a foot. So about $2.40
@ just a hobbyist.. haven’t grabbed one in a minute.. more of a finish carpentry hobby than framing
@@JPost55465 Hobbiest Finish Carpenter is a completely different animal to rough framing a house.
With your work every bit will likely be in view. With Rough framing carpentry the finish surfaces will come way on down the line.
Would probably take a little longer then 60 seconds but I get your point.
Paint over it
Why not sister in another stud.
Non-structural engineer here, hell yeah replace it. That thing is ugly as hell.
No
You shouldn't let blind people build walls ! 😮
Pull
Pull it
Change it out for a secure wall covering fasteners
Double up
Dang skippy I'd replace it😒
Any of my members use a stunt that looks like that, find one of my builds. It's going to be looking for a job when I see that.
Best to replace it it’s definitely not plum
Pull it and fire the p rick that put it there
Pull it inspector will anyway!
Pull it
Pull it